Humanitário19 de novembro de 2026

The IPC's March 2024 analysis projected famine as imminent in northern Gaza, but its June review said available evidence did not indicate famine was then occurring.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld é o pseudônimo da editoria Fatos e Mitos da Hasbara. Os artigos desta editoria são escritos e publicados automaticamente por inteligência artificial, sem revisão humana antes da publicação.

Mito

The IPC officially declared that full-scale famine was actively occurring in northern Gaza in mid-2024.

Fato

The IPC's March 2024 analysis projected famine as imminent in northern Gaza, but its June review said available evidence did not indicate famine was then occurring. The committee still warned of catastrophic food insecurity and high, sustained risk.

The claim that the United Nations Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) formally confirmed active famine in northern Gaza in mid-2024 confuses a forecast with a later assessment. In March 2024, the IPC warned famine was imminent under its most likely scenario. In June, after reviewing newer information, its Famine Review Committee (FRC) concluded that available evidence did not indicate famine was occurring at that time. The same June assessment described catastrophic hunger and continuing high risk; it did not describe a safe or adequate food situation.

March warning was a projection

On March 18, the IPC published an analysis covering February through July. It said famine was imminent in the northern governorates and projected that it could occur between mid-March and May. The projection depended on a scenario in which conflict continued and access for humanitarian deliveries remained very limited. The IPC described North Gaza and Gaza as IPC Phase 5 (Catastrophe) in its most likely scenario, with around 210,000 people projected to face that household-level category.

The IPC's March analysis described a projected future famine rather than an already confirmed area-level famine. Its headline called famine imminent, and its body described a future projection. The World Food Programme (WFP) likewise wrote that famine was expected to arrive between then and May and quoted Executive Director Cindy McCain warning that action was needed before famine was declared. Her warning itself distinguished the risk from a declaration.

That distinction matters because the IPC uses “Catastrophe” for household-level conditions and “Famine” for an area-level classification. The IPC's explanation of famine classifications says an area can be classified as famine only when widespread starvation, acute malnutrition, and excess deaths occur together. Its methods allow classification with reasonable evidence when two thresholds are clearly met and evidence indicates the third is likely met. A household facing IPC Phase 5 conditions is not, by itself, a formal finding that the whole area meets famine criteria.

June review updated the picture

On June 25, the IPC issued a new analysis using information available through June 4. The FRC reviewed the analysis after the IPC's March projection and an earlier FEWS NET assessment raised concern about possible famine in April. For April, the committee said uncertainty and lack of agreement among supporting evidence prevented it from determining whether famine thresholds had been crossed. Its later review stated that the available evidence did not indicate famine was occurring.

The FRC's June report found the analysis team's current classifications of IPC Phase 4 (Emergency) plausible for all areas for May 1 through June 15. The accompanying IPC snapshot recorded that deliveries of food and nutrition services to northern governorates increased in March and April and appeared to have temporarily eased conditions. It also warned that aid access remained constrained and that improvements could quickly reverse.

The IPC did not minimize the emergency. Its June snapshot estimated that about 2.13 million people across the territory faced acute food insecurity at Crisis level or worse during May 1 to June 15, including nearly 343,000 people in household-level Catastrophe. It projected that 495,000 people could face Catastrophe through September. It also said the whole territory was classified in Emergency at area level, with high famine risk as long as conflict continued and humanitarian access remained restricted.

Risk and confirmation are different findings

The IPC's June report said the FRC considered famine risk plausible across all areas under the analysis team's stated assumptions. A risk finding means a reasonable possibility of future deterioration; it is not a declaration that famine is already occurring. The June snapshot explicitly explains that areas may contain households in Catastrophe without qualifying for an area-level famine classification if widespread acute malnutrition and deaths have not materialized at the required levels.

The UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, summarizing the June IPC update, made the timeline clear: February's analysis had projected famine would likely occur in the north by the end of May, but available evidence did not suggest famine was then occurring there, where deliveries and nutrition services had increased in March and April. OCHA also reported that high risk persisted as long as hostilities and restricted access continued.

So the accurate account is neither “the IPC confirmed famine in northern Gaza in mid-2024” nor “there was no hunger emergency.” March brought a grave projection; June brought a revised assessment that did not confirm famine while documenting severe food insecurity and continued danger. Repeating the projection as a formal confirmation erases the reassessment. Treating the reassessment as proof that people were not suffering erases the IPC's own figures and warnings.

Fontes

  1. 1
  2. 2
    Famine imminent in northern Gaza, new report warnshttps://www.wfp.org/news/famine-imminent-northern-gaza-new-report-warnsNão confiável
  3. 3
    Famine Review Committee: Gaza Strip, June 2024https://www.ipcinfo.org/fileadmin/user_upload/ipcinfo/docs/IPC_Famine_Review_Committee_Report_Gaza_June2024.pdfNão confiável
  4. 4
    Gaza Strip: IPC Acute Food Insecurity Special Snapshot, 1 May - 30 September 2024https://www.ipcinfo.org/fileadmin/user_upload/ipcinfo/docs/IPC_Gaza_Strip_Acute_Food_Insecurity_MaySept2024_Special_Snapshot.pdfNão confiável
  5. 5
    Humanitarian Situation Update #184: Gaza Striphttps://www.ochaopt.org/content/humanitarian-situation-update-184-gaza-stripNão confiável
  6. 6
    Famine factshttps://www.ipcinfo.org/famine-facts/enNão confiável

Configurações de acessibilidade

Essas configurações são salvas neste dispositivo.

Pré-visualização

Leia com clareza, do seu jeito

Ajuste a página enquanto lê. Explorar materiais

Texto
Tamanho do textoAplica-se a todo o site.
Cor e contraste
Tema
Movimento
AnimaçõesO padrão do dispositivo segue a opção de redução de movimento.